The OJHL Goaltender-of-the-Year Award is awarded to the goaltender adjudged to have demonstrated the greatest all-round ability at his position throughout the regular season. The 2012-13 season marked the first time this award was presented.
Year - Player - Team
- 2024-25 - Marcus Vandenberg, Leamington Flyers
- 2023-24 - Noah Pak, Collingwood Blues
- 2022-23 - James Norton, Toronto Jr. Canadiens
- 2021-22 - James Gray, North York Rangers
- 2019-20 - Nathan Torchia, Georgetown Raiders
- 2018-19 - Jett Alexander, North York Rangers
- 2017-18 - Fraser Kirk, Newmarket Hurricanes
- 2016-17 - Josh Astorino, Georgetown Raiders
- 2015-16 - Andrew Masters, Georgetown Raiders
- 2014-15 - Justin Kapelmaster, Trenton Golden Hawks
- 2013-14 - Kevin Entmaa, Aurora Tigers
- 2012-13 - Charlie Finn, Kingston Voyageurs