This award goes to the leading regular season goaltender statistically with the best goals against average during the regular season.
Year – Goalie – Team – GAA
- 2023-24 – Noah Pak, Collingwood (1.30 gaa)
- 2022-23 – James Norton, Toronto Jr. Canadiens (1.88 gaa)
- 2021-22 – James Gray, North York (1.96 gaa)
- 2019-20 – Andrew Rose, Collingwood Colts (1.77 gaa)
- 2018-19 – Jett Alexander, North York (1.67 gaa)
- 2017-18 – Colby Muise, North York (1.81 gaa)
- 2016-17 – Stefano Durante, Cobourg (1.92 gaa)
- 2015-16 – Daniel Urbani, Trenton (1.69 gaa)
- 2014-15 – Stefano Durante, Cobourg (1.79 gaa)
- 2013-14 – Kevin Entmaa, Aurora (2.16 gaa)
- 2012-13 – Charlie Finn, Kingston (2.15 gaa)
- 2011-12 – James Prigione, Oakville (2.04 gaa)
- 2010-11 – Charlie Finn, Kingston (1.92 gaa)
- 2009-10 – Joel Vienneau, Kingston (2.16 gaa) OJAHL
- 2009-10 – Jordan Ruby, Wellington (2.18 gaa) CCHL
- 2008-09 – Dalton McGrath, Couchiching (1.65 gaa)
- 2007-08 – Jeff Dawson, Huntsville (2.11 gaa)
- 2006-07 – Edward Pasquale, Wellington (1.92 gaa)
- 2005-06 – Bryan Scott, Bowmanville (1.92 gaa)
- 2004-05 – Russ Brownell, Wexford (1.91 gaa)
- 2003-04 – Chris Whitley, Aurora (1.64 gaa)
- 2002-03 – Dayne Davis, Wellington (1.40 gaa)
- 2001-02 – Dan LaCosta, Wellington (1.96 gaa)
- 2000-01 – Jamie Fraresso, Newmarket (2.44 gaa)
- 1999-00 – Nate Bedford, Lindsay (2.02 gaa)
- 1998-99 – Jonathan Forrest, Collingwood (2.16 gaa)
- 1997-98 – Jeremy Wenzel, Milton (2.07 gaa)
- 1996-97 – Colin March, Kingston (2.36 gaa)
- 1995-96 – Colin March, Kingston (2.64 gaa)
- 1994-95 – Patrick Desrochers, Barrie (3.08 gaa)
- 1993-94 – Ryan Caley, Orillia (2.15 gaa)
- 1992-93 – Tony Maglietta, Barrie (2.65 gaa)
- 1986-87 – Curtis Joseph, Richmond Hill (4.61 gaa)
- 1985-86 – Jim Dubke, Orillia (3.58 gaa)
- 1984-85 – Dennis Schrapp, Orillia (3.53 gaa)
- 1983-84 – Scott Yearwood, Dixie (4.30 gaa)
- 1982-83 – Don Fawcett, North York (3.40 gaa)
- 1981-82 – Wayne MacDougall, Guelph (2.63 gaa)
- 1980-81 – Dan Burrows, Belleville (2.88 gaa)
- 1979-80 – Ray Pilon, Belleville (3.48 gaa)
- 1978-79 – Burt Gustavsson, Guelph (3.56 gaa)
- 1977-78 – Rick Clark, Guelph (3.90 gaa)
- 1976-77 – Kevin Walton, North York (3.24 gaa)
- 1975-76 – Steve Jones, North York (3.09 gaa)
- 1974-75 – Mike Ryckman, Whitby (3.41 gaa)
- 1973-74 – Kevin Walton, Vaughan (2.48 gaa)
- 1972-74 – Gary Carr, Richmond Hill (2.90 gaa)